-Effective, non-clumpy -Rated 4 on EWG database (moderate hazard)
-Good price ($8) -One ingredient rated 6 (Benzyl Alcohol)
-Widely available -CoverGirl has not signed Compact for Safe Cosmetics
-Fewer synthetic ingredients than -Description says "a touch of nature" but doesn't specify
other CoverGirl mascaras
Conclusion: CoverGirl is certainly not the greenest cosmetics company around, and their NatureLuxe line seems like greenwashing to me, but it is a great step for such a big player in the makeup industry. I like the way this product looks and feels, and though I probably will not buy it again, (I'm still on the hunt for a mascara without ANY synthetic ingredients) I'd recommend this product to green-beauty beginners.